The Curious AI Case of a Kirchner Painting in Limbo
Artificial intelligence is playing a bigger role in artwork authentication, but how should AI results be weighed against good old human judgement?

Ernst Ludwig Kirchner, Black Cat (Katze in Blumenwiese), 1924–26. Courtesy WOS Gallery
Artificial intelligence is becoming an increasingly visible – and polarising – tool in artwork authentication. Over the last decade, several companies have developed systems that they claim can identify an artist’s hand using digital images with unerring accuracy. But adoption of the technology also raises existential questions for art experts. For example, how should AI results be weighed against provenance research, technical examination and good old human judgement?
While the market continues to be wary of solely relying on AI authentication, some players have adopted its use. They include Zürich’s Germann Auction House, which partnered with Switzerland-based AI authentication company Art Recognition to authenticate a watercolour by Russian artist Marianne von Werefkin. It ended up selling for just under US$17,000, almost double its high estimate of $9,000.
Fabio Sidler, an auctioneer at Germann Auction House told ARTnews last year that he wouldn’t be surprised if there are “critical voices” about only relying on AI to authenticate the artwork. “However, I expect an overall positive reception of the news that we are embracing the groundbreaking method of Art Recognition,” he added.
Industry watchers believe that AI authentication must be complemented with expert knowledge and provenance research. “Any company using AI to fully attribute a painting should be treated with serious doubt,” Simon Gillespie, who runs an art authentication and restoration studio in London, previously told me. Carina Popovici, Art Recognition’s CEO, is on the same page. “I strongly believe that the future of art authentication lies in the collaboration between AI and experts,” she says.
A more recent case involving Art Recognition and a disputed Ernst Ludwig Kirchner painting has shed further light on AI’s role in the art market.
Katze in Blumenwiese was sold in 1980 by a Swiss gallery as a work by the Swiss artist Albert Müller. The painting had come from the estate of Kirchner, the German Expressionist painter, and bears an estate stamp. A handwritten note by Roman N. Ketterer, who administered Kirchner’s estate, states: ‘nicht von E.L. Kirchner’ (‘not by E.L. Kirchner’).
However, the attribution to Müller didn’t stick. In 1981 art historian Beat Stutzer excluded the painting from his catalogue raisonné of Müller’s work. Over the following decades, a number of specialists came to support an attribution to Kirchner.
In 2008 the Swiss Institute for Art History (SIK) in Zürich held a symposium specifically devoted to the painting. Around a dozen experts in art history and the natural sciences took part, and a clear majority supported an attribution to Kirchner. Among them was Eberhard W. Kornfeld, the influential Swiss auctioneer, dealer and Kirchner specialist.
But Wolfgang Henze, the leading expert associated with the Kirchner Archive, remained unconvinced. According to a 2025 account of the case by Swiss art lawyer Andreas Ritter, SIK restorers who examined the painting in 2008 found differences in its brushwork compared with paintings securely attributed to Kirchner. Henze continued to investigate the work’s provenance and documentation and to compare it with paintings by artists associated with Kirchner.
The painting consequently remained outside the Kirchner catalogue raisonné.
Art Recognition became involved in 2022. Popovici tells The Art Journal that she knew nothing about the painting’s history when she received the work.
“For us it was just a painting to analyse like any other,” she says. Her company’s AI system, trained on authenticated Kirchner works, returned a 97.3 percent probability that the painting was authentic, according to Popovici. She says Art Recognition conducted no further examination after delivering the result.
Swiss gallery Galerie WOS presented it at Art Karlsruhe in Germany in February 2026. The gallery didn’t respond to any of my questions, so it’s unclear if the work was offered for sale or sold at the fair.
However, in an email seen by The Art Journal, Claudius Ochsner, WOS’s director, informed Popovici that the gallery had received the Kirchner Archive’s report, which recognises Katze in Blumenwiese as an authentic Ernst Ludwig Kirchner
When contacted by The Art Journal, the Kirchner Archive said the decision to authenticate the painting followed Art Recognition’s analysis, and that the archive had conducted additional, unspecified examinations on top of the AI authentication.
The change in fate of this painting – from what many human specialists considered a ‘fake’ to becoming a ‘real’ one, bolstered by AI analysis – doesn’t quite show that AI can replace art experts. In this case, the technology did not operate independently of the established authentication system. Instead, an AI-generated probability entered a case that had already been examined by specialists and was subsequently considered as part of further research by the artist’s archive.
For Popovici, the significance of the result lies in the difference between the AI analysis and the expert opinions that preceded it.
“The 2008 symposium produced a great deal of expert opinion, and it did not move the case,” she says. “Adding a 13th or 14th specialist to that room would probably not have moved it either, because it would have been essentially the same kind of evidence.”
Art Recognition’s analysis, she adds, provided a different form of evidence: a data-driven assessment produced through a documented and repeatable method.
“Our model was trained on authenticated works by Kirchner and returned a 97.3 percent probability that the painting is authentic,” Popovici says.
The archive’s decision, however, was not based on that number alone. Its description of the AI result as ‘one part’ of a much larger investigation leaves open what the other parts were and how they were weighed.
That is also what distinguishes the Kirchner case from examples in which AI has been used as the sole authentication method. Here, the technology entered an existing dispute and was followed by further examination before an established attribution authority changed its position.
The 2026 Art Karlsruhe magazine describes Katze in Blumenwiese as ‘a verified/authenticated work made by [Kirchner’s] own hand’ and states that it is to be included in the artist’s new catalogue raisonné.
Related content
News

Margot Heller to Step Down as South London Gallery Director
Heller leaves after an over 25-year tenure that saw visitor numbers increase tenfold and the gallery’s footprint more than triple

Ownership Claims Shadow New York Auction Week
Ownership claims have disrupted New York’s biggest auction week of the year, with Sotheby’s settling a restitution claim over its $180 million Van Gogh and Christie’s withdrawing a Frida Kahlo painting

Paris Museum to Lend Works to Hong Kong amid Tibet Dispute
Around 150 objects will trace over a millennium of artistic exchange across Eurasia, in a partnership with a Paris museum facing protests over its labelling of Tibet

Kader Attia Reveals Theme for 2027 Kochi-Muziris Biennale
The artist and curator has unveiled a theme centred on dreams, memory and repair, set against the predictive logic of AI

Dakar Biennale Opens 2026 Edition This Week
The Biennale brings together 74 artists and collectives across the Senegalese capital for a monthlong celebration of contemporary African art and design

Paisley Museum to Reopen in 2027 After £68.7 Million Redevelopment
Closed since 2018, the museum reopens as a single campus of galleries, gardens and the restored Coats Observatory, in the first reimagining of its 150-year history

Sculptures Smashed at Turkish Border Crossing
Sculptures headed for an exhibition set to open in London were smashed at the Turkey–Bulgaria border

Bronze Sculpture by Jean Arp Stolen at Art Cologne
The theft has prompted questions about security at the fair. Ludorff Gallery says the 28cm bronze disappeared from its booth during a 15-minute window on Sunday

Loop Barcelona Opens 24th Edition
Loop Barcelona, the international platform dedicated to artists’ cinema and the moving image, is staging its 24th edition across the city from 10 to 21 November

Art Basel Offers Paris Exhibitors 20 Percent Discount After Early Closure
All 211 galleries at last month’s fair will have booth fees cut, following dealer demands for compensation

Collector Elie Khouri to Create Dubai Home for His Private Foundation
Due to open in 2028, the Elie Khouri Art Foundation will draw its first exhibitions from the collector’s holdings of more than 300 artists

Art Gallery of Ontario to open Dani Reiss Gallery in 2027
The five-floor addition, which will display nearly 400 works, is due to open in September 2027
