Advertisment

Ownership Claims Shadow New York Auction Week

Ownership claims have disrupted New York’s biggest auction week of the year, with Sotheby’s settling a restitution claim over its $180 million Van Gogh and Christie’s withdrawing a Frida Kahlo painting

The Art Journal18 November, 2026
Vincent van Gogh - Châtaigniers en fleurs (Detail). Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Vincent van Gogh - Châtaigniers en fleurs (Detail). Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

New York’s high-profile auction week, with more than $2 billion of art on offer, has been shadowed by two ownership disputes: a Nazi-era restitution claim over a Van Gogh, which was settled a day before the sale, and a Mexican cultural-heritage claim that forced the withdrawal of a Kahlo painting.

On 17 November, Sotheby’s said the sellers of Vincent van Gogh’s Châtaigniers en fleurs (1890), the Blaquier-Arrieta family, had reached an agreement with the descendants of Hedwig and Samuel Fischer. According to Sotheby’s catalogue records, Samuel Fischer acquired the painting in 1909. His heirs argued that the Jewish family was compelled to part with it in 1936 after fleeing Berlin. Representatives of the heirs asked Sotheby’s to withdraw the painting unless it could establish the sale had been voluntary. Sotheby’s said its own research had not established duress but that it was committed to a resolution. Guaranteed by the house and estimated at about $180m, against Van Gogh’s auction record of $117.2m set in 2022, the painting remains in Sotheby’s Blaquier-Arrieta collection sale on 18 November.

It was a different story at Christie’s. The house withdrew Frida Kahlo’s Congreso de los pueblos por la paz (1952), estimated at between $2m and $3.5m, from its 20th Century Evening Sale on 17 November, hours before the auction. Mexico’s Instituto Nacional de Bellas Artes y Literatura (INBAL), the state body responsible for the country’s artistic heritage, had asked the house to produce documentation of the work’s provenance and ownership. Defendamos la Colección Gelman, a Mexican collective campaigning against the export of nationally protected works, contends that the work belongs to the Casa Azul trust Diego Rivera established after Kahlo’s death. INBAL has said Kahlo gave the painting away during her lifetime and that it left Mexico before her work was declared an artistic monument in 1984, so the export ban on her works does not apply.

Neither dispute dented sales. Sotheby’s opened on 16 November with two evening sales totalling $378.7m with fees, and Christie’s went ahead without the Kahlo to make $521m, against $390.1m a year ago.

Share:
FacebookTwitter

News

Advertisment
Vista de l’exposició de Momu & No Es a House of Chappaz, City Screen. Courtesy Loop Festival

Loop Barcelona Opens 24th Edition

Loop Barcelona, the international platform dedicated to artists’ cinema and the moving image, is staging its 24th edition across the city from 10 to 21 November

The Art Journal