Private Views: Forty-Eight Hours with Matthew Barney’s River of Fundament
Twelve years on, the operatic film, once criticised for its scatological excesses and sprawling narrative, was screened to a sold-out audience in New York

Matthew Barney and Jonathan Bepler, River of Fundament, 2014. Courtesy of the artist and Gladstone. Photo: Hugo Glendinning
More than 800 people came to the Masonic Hall of New York in Manhattan last weekend for a rare chance to see River of Fundament, the epic five-and-a-half-hour operatic film by artist Matthew Barney and composer Jonathan Bepler that has gained mythical status since its release in 2014.
The queue for the sold-out event began at the 24th Street entrance of the Beaux-Arts building – which houses the Freemasons’ headquarters – and snaked around Sixth Avenue to 23rd Street. The Grand Lodge Room, a striking 1,200-seat hall with a stained-glass ceiling and hand-carved mouldings, was an appropriately grand setting for the occasion, given how few screenings of River of Fundament have been held over the last decade.
After its premiere at the Brooklyn Academy of Music, followed by presentations in museums and festivals around the world, River of Fundament was widely criticised for its gratuitous scatological and sexual extremism, including scenes of animal carcasses, sewers overflowing with faeces and rim jobs. Some argued that its narrative was incoherent, while others complained about the run time, and there were reports of mass walkouts. Reviewing a 2016 screening at the Portland Art Museum, one critic wrote: ‘Ten minutes into the nearly six-hour River of Fundament film cycle, I began to wonder when it would end. The feeling never abated.’
But audiences have since had time to digest its excesses and reconsider its merits, and there was a palpably different feeling in the air. The presentation was divided into three parts and, although the theatre grew emptier after each 30-minute intermission, those who remained seemed receptive to – or even appreciative of – this opportunity that was unlikely to happen again any time soon. Some had served as extras but had never seen the film; others had memories of its production, like when a replica of Norman Mailer’s home was being floated down the East River in 2012.
River of Fundament is loosely based on Mailer’s 1983 epic Ancient Evenings, a 709-page novel set in pharaonic Egypt that took Mailer ten years to write and divided reviewers on its release. The New York Times called it a ‘disaster’, while the New York Review of Books suggested that its characters were stand-ins for Mailer himself, who had then fallen out of favour after his 1960 stabbing of his then wife Adele, to which he pleaded guilty, and amid long-running charges of misogyny. In turn, reviews of River of Fundament were frequently diverted to its source material.
In the Los Angeles Times in 2015, art critic Christopher Knight discussed the parallels between Ancient Evenings and River of Fundament. ‘Mailer, looking back from atop his own rubble-strewn empire to civilization’s mysterious origins, strains to make sense of a magic-infused, dust-laden past and his own place in history,’ Knight wrote. ‘So does Barney’s project. It’s not pretty. Yet scatology doesn’t begin to describe what flows through Barney’s distended art, where Western civilization’s foundation is also humanity’s anus. The experience is unique if also unfulfilling.’

Matthew Barney and Jonathan Bepler, River of Fundament, 2014. Photo: Chris SeguineCourtesy of the artist and Gladstone.
The idea to adapt Ancient Evenings came from Mailer, who, in his lifetime, knew Barney and considered him a genius. His 1979 book The Executioner’s Song, which won the Pulitzer Prize the following year, inspired Barney’s Cremaster 2 (1999), in which Mailer has a cameo as Houdini. Mailer was dismayed that Ancient Evenings had been cast aside and wanted a greater legacy for it. Barney and Bepler began working on River of Fundament in 2007, the year that Mailer died, and made him the protagonist of the film, whom viewers see undergoing three reincarnations. Mailer’s son, John Buffalo Mailer, plays the youngest Mailer, while the late Milford Graves and Chief Dave Beautiful Bald Eagle play the others. Barney has said that the film took some liberties that would not have been made if Mailer were alive.
Scenes from River of Fundament have been dissected ad nauseam and are not worth repeating here. The more interesting question is how conversations around the film have evolved and how the artworld has come to think about it and its place in art history. The passage of time, and the scarcity of opportunities to see the film, means there has been room for a broader consideration of what Barney and Bepler set out to achieve.
For this screening of the film, guests were given a napkin and told it would be part of the performance. Across three floors of the Masonic Hall, there was a coffee service, a merch table with $40 (£30) posters, bars throughout and a room with tables stocked with free White Castle burgers and onion rings, which were quickly depleted and prompted their own round of scatological jokes. The event began with a pipe organ and trumpet performance before Barney asked the audience to wave their napkins to honour the cast members who had died, including his longtime dealer Barbara Gladstone, jazz musician Dr Lonnie Smith and artist Lawrence Weiner. It ended around 10pm, when droves of glassy-eyed guests spilled out onto the streets, emerging from the eight-hour trip.
The following day at Public Records in Brooklyn, a smaller crowd shuffled into a room for a talk moderated by ARTnews executive editor Andy Battaglia, who led a conversation with Barney and Bepler about the film and the singular language they have developed through their collaboration dating back to the 1990s, from the Cremaster Cycle (1994–2002), which established the expansive ambitions they would bring to River of Fundament, and, since, Redoubt (2018) and Secondary (2023).
Several audience questions shifted the conversation back to Mailer. When Barney was asked what it was like to revisit the film after all these years, he reiterated that the main problem when River of Fundament was first shown was Mailer himself, who was a much more polarising figure at the time, and audiences who perhaps had opinions about Mailer as a cultural presence. “The audience was pretty young last night, so I’m guessing that somebody who’s 30 doesn’t have that baggage,” he said. Indeed, an adaptation of The Executioner’s Song, announced this month, is in the works starring Jacob Elordi, who has so far attracted no comparable criticism for taking the role.
Barney also categorically countered previous simplistic readings that the film is a tribute to Mailer, saying that he is primarily interested in “archetypal characters”, who can be equally problematic and compelling. “Our approach with [Ancient Evenings] was always about creating a bridge into some other space. It wasn’t about adapting and celebrating it,” he said. “It was about pushing back and using it as a kind of portal to the space. At the time, that was a little tricky because it was more of an obstacle. So I think that felt lighter to me. Or the abstraction, I think, that we’re both interested in, felt more accessible.”

River of Fundament at the Masonic Hall NYC. Photography by Anthony Flores. Courtesy of the artist and Gladstone.
The talk also revealed some of the technical process behind the film, from the improvisational nature of working with non-instruments and non-musicians to create music to how animals were sourced for the film from taxidermists, handlers and pet owners. In one scene, we see Mailer’s son open the carcass of a cow, withdrawing a dead calf, then climbing inside; no one on set knew the cow was pregnant until it was a struggle to cut it open, and they decided to make use of the situation.
The weekend closed with more existential questions, including when one audience member asked whether Barney believed River of Fundament offered a hopeful view of reincarnation, or a more cyclical, fatalistic version in which nothing ever truly changes.
“The ending feels like a series of deaths, one after another, accompanied by these musical moments, one after another,” Barney said. “It made me think about how death elicits a song or emotion, and perhaps a beautiful form that you couldn’t otherwise have made. I think that warmth probably brings something alive. There’s both the shittiness of the present and the shittiness in the scenes. But I also wondered whether that shittiness creates a kind of warmth that’s inversely proportionate – the worse things get, the stronger the warmth.”
River of Fundament was screened by Unsound and New People’s Cinema Club, Masonic Hall, New York, 14 November
Related content
Private Views: Forty-Eight Hours with Matthew Barney’s River of Fundament
Help I Hate...My Freeloader
Will ‘Say What You Pay’ Open Up Arts Jobs?
News

Margot Heller to Step Down as South London Gallery Director
Heller leaves after an over 25-year tenure that saw visitor numbers increase tenfold and the gallery’s footprint more than triple

Ownership Claims Shadow New York Auction Week
Ownership claims have disrupted New York’s biggest auction week of the year, with Sotheby’s settling a restitution claim over its $180 million Van Gogh and Christie’s withdrawing a Frida Kahlo painting

Paris Museum to Lend Works to Hong Kong amid Tibet Dispute
Around 150 objects will trace over a millennium of artistic exchange across Eurasia, in a partnership with a Paris museum facing protests over its labelling of Tibet

Kader Attia Reveals Theme for 2027 Kochi-Muziris Biennale
The artist and curator has unveiled a theme centred on dreams, memory and repair, set against the predictive logic of AI

Dakar Biennale Opens 2026 Edition This Week
The Biennale brings together 74 artists and collectives across the Senegalese capital for a monthlong celebration of contemporary African art and design

Paisley Museum to Reopen in 2027 After £68.7 Million Redevelopment
Closed since 2018, the museum reopens as a single campus of galleries, gardens and the restored Coats Observatory, in the first reimagining of its 150-year history

Sculptures Smashed at Turkish Border Crossing
Sculptures headed for an exhibition set to open in London were smashed at the Turkey–Bulgaria border

Bronze Sculpture by Jean Arp Stolen at Art Cologne
The theft has prompted questions about security at the fair. Ludorff Gallery says the 28cm bronze disappeared from its booth during a 15-minute window on Sunday

Loop Barcelona Opens 24th Edition
Loop Barcelona, the international platform dedicated to artists’ cinema and the moving image, is staging its 24th edition across the city from 10 to 21 November

Art Basel Offers Paris Exhibitors 20 Percent Discount After Early Closure
All 211 galleries at last month’s fair will have booth fees cut, following dealer demands for compensation

Collector Elie Khouri to Create Dubai Home for His Private Foundation
Due to open in 2028, the Elie Khouri Art Foundation will draw its first exhibitions from the collector’s holdings of more than 300 artists

Art Gallery of Ontario to open Dani Reiss Gallery in 2027
The five-floor addition, which will display nearly 400 works, is due to open in September 2027
