Help! I Hate My... Dodgy Trading
Artworld Agony Aunt Charlotte Jansen answers a staffer whose gallery has been busy with some dodgy deals

Christian Bale in The Big Short (2015). Courtesy Paramount
I recently discovered what appears to be some very unethical trading going on at the commercial gallery where I work, and I honestly don't know what to do about it.
I don’t want to give too many identifying details, but I came across information about some transactions that didn’t seem right. The more I looked, the more uncomfortable I became. It appears that certain people may be benefitting from deals in ways that don’t seem transparent or fair, and there may be a significant conflict of interest involved. I'm not sure whether what I’ve seen is actually illegal, but it certainly feels wrong, and I’m struggling with the fact that I now know about it.
The difficult thing is that this isn’t a huge company where I can simply go to a compliance department or speak to someone completely independent. The people who may be involved are quite senior, and the artworld is small – everyone seems to know everyone, so I’m worried that raising concerns could come back to me very quickly.
Part of me thinks I have a responsibility to say something. If I stay quiet, am I effectively allowing the behaviour to continue? But another part of me is worried about my job and my reputation. I don't want to become known as the difficult employee who made accusations that turned out to be wrong… So what should I do?
Yikes. I do not envy you, but I would also hazard a guess you’re far from the first person to find yourself in this situation in the artworld, and you won’t be the last in what is a notoriously slippery, ambiguous and unregulated market. Your situation reminds me of the case Orlando Whitfield recounts in his All That Glitters exposé of the artworld’s biggest art fraud – Inigo Philbrick’s $86 million Ponzi-style scheme, selling shares of artwork he did not own. That, however, was firmly in the realm of the illegal, and Philbrick ended up in jail…
Finding yourself in possession of information that makes you question the ethics of your workplace is an incredibly uncomfortable position, particularly in an industry as small and interconnected as the artworld, as you rightly point out. You are right to take it seriously, but you are also right to be cautious. However, I believe there is a big difference between doing nothing and taking a little time to work out the safest and most responsible way to act.
The first thing I would suggest is that you stop investigating. It is understandable that, having spotted something that didn’t add up, you started looking more closely into things. But you don’t need to become the gallery’s amateur detective – it’s not your job to prove that someone has committed a crime (you don’t mention your role at the gallery, but I don’t think it’s legal). If you do decide to raise the matter with someone, you need to report what you have genuinely observed and allow the appropriate person or organisation to investigate it instead.
Make a private, factual record of what you already know. Note the dates, transactions, documents you legitimately had access to, and what specifically concerned you. Always keep facts separate from assumptions. ‘This transaction took place between X and Y’ is very different from ‘X and Y were deliberately concealing something’. That distinction could become important later, if this does devolve into something bigger.
Also, be very careful about how you preserve information. Don’t take confidential documents home, forward sensitive emails to your personal account or access files you aren’t authorised to see simply because you are worried about what they contain. You want to protect yourself, not inadvertently create another problem.
Your next question is where to take this concern. If your gallery has a whistleblowing policy, complaints procedure, compliance contact, HR function, independent board-member or external adviser, find out what the formal route is. You don’t necessarily have to confront the people you suspect. In fact, if they are senior or potentially involved themselves, doing so could be the least sensible option.
And before you make a serious allegation, consider getting some kind of confidential independent advice. A solicitor with experience in employment or whistleblowing matters can help you understand both your rights and your risks. This is particularly important if you think the conduct could potentially involve fraud, money laundering, tax issues, sanctions, theft or other criminal behaviour.
I would also resist the temptation to sound the alarm among your colleagues – as you seem to have done so far. You may desperately want to ask someone, ‘Have you noticed this too?’ But once an allegation starts circulating, it becomes gossip and hearsay. Things could easily get out of hand. At the same time, be honest with yourself. Is this genuinely about unethical conduct, or could there be an innocent explanation you haven’t considered? Are you relying on information you only partially understand? Asking these questions doesn’t mean talking yourself out of doing the right thing; it means making sure you aren’t confusing suspicion with fact.
There is, of course, a moral question here: If I know something is wrong and say nothing, am I part of the problem? I think this question applies to so many of us working in different areas across the cultural sector, all the time. But it’s often not as simple as that. You are an employee, not a regulator, investigator or law-enforcement agency. You have responsibilities to yourself as well as to your employer and the wider industry. Equally, don’t let the fear of being ‘difficult’ silence you. There is a world of difference between making a malicious accusation and raising a good-faith concern because something genuinely doesn’t look right. You don’t need absolute certainty before asking for advice. You simply need to be honest about what you know, what you don’t know and why it concerns you. Your discomfort is worth listening to.
Most importantly, don’t sacrifice your entire career in an attempt to become the person who single-handedly cleans up the artworld. If the behaviour is serious, there should be proper mechanisms for dealing with it. Your role is to put the concern in the right hands, not to conduct a crusade. You may ultimately decide that you need to report what you’ve seen. If you do, you can do so calmly and professionally rather than dramatically. And if it turns out there is an innocent explanation after all (I have to say, I find this option unlikely), you will at least have handled your concern responsibly.
Related content
Private Views: Forty-Eight Hours with Matthew Barney’s River of Fundament
Help I Hate...My Freeloader
Will ‘Say What You Pay’ Open Up Arts Jobs?
News

ART SG Unveils Fifth-Edition Line-up For Singapore Art Week 2027
ART SG’s fifth edition opens Singapore Art Week in January, bringing more than 110 galleries to Marina Bay Sands in a second year of co-presentation with S.E.A. Focus

Stedelijk Museum Amsterdam Appoints Krist Gruijthuijsen as New Director
The Dutch curator and critic Krist Gruijthuijsen will succeed Rein Wolfs in July 2027

Margot Heller to Step Down as South London Gallery Director
Heller leaves after an over 25-year tenure that saw visitor numbers increase tenfold and the gallery’s footprint more than triple

Ownership Claims Shadow New York Auction Week
Ownership claims have disrupted New York’s biggest auction week of the year, with Sotheby’s settling a restitution claim over its $180 million Van Gogh and Christie’s withdrawing a Frida Kahlo painting

Paris Museum to Lend Works to Hong Kong amid Tibet Dispute
Around 150 objects will trace over a millennium of artistic exchange across Eurasia, in a partnership with a Paris museum facing protests over its labelling of Tibet

Kader Attia Reveals Theme for 2027 Kochi-Muziris Biennale
The artist and curator has unveiled a theme centred on dreams, memory and repair, set against the predictive logic of AI

Dakar Biennale Opens 2026 Edition This Week
The Biennale brings together 74 artists and collectives across the Senegalese capital for a monthlong celebration of contemporary African art and design

Paisley Museum to Reopen in 2027 After £68.7 Million Redevelopment
Closed since 2018, the museum reopens as a single campus of galleries, gardens and the restored Coats Observatory, in the first reimagining of its 150-year history

Sculptures Smashed at Turkish Border Crossing
Sculptures headed for an exhibition set to open in London were smashed at the Turkey–Bulgaria border

Bronze Sculpture by Jean Arp Stolen at Art Cologne
The theft has prompted questions about security at the fair. Ludorff Gallery says the 28cm bronze disappeared from its booth during a 15-minute window on Sunday

Loop Barcelona Opens 24th Edition
Loop Barcelona, the international platform dedicated to artists’ cinema and the moving image, is staging its 24th edition across the city from 10 to 21 November

Art Basel Offers Paris Exhibitors 20 Percent Discount After Early Closure
All 211 galleries at last month’s fair will have booth fees cut, following dealer demands for compensation
