Bet the Lot: What Happened When New York’s Auctions Met Kalshi
Artnet’s partnership with Kalshi promised to open the art market to everyone. New York’s auction week opened it to one Van Gogh and a basketball. For Messy Business, Jeni Fulton reports
.jpg%3F2026-11-20T16%3A47%3A11.171Z&w=2560&q=85)
Auction Room, Christie's 1808. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
On Wednesday 11 November, Artnet News ran a story in its Market section under the byline ‘Artnet Editors’. The company had become the ‘official art partner’ of Kalshi, the US-regulated prediction-market platform: Artnet would propose markets, Kalshi would design the contracts and settle the bets. In layperson’s terms, you can now bet on whether a Van Gogh will go for over $200 million at Sotheby’s, or whether Basquiat will break his auction record. In an art market where inside information is already a form of currency, and many lots are guaranteed at auction (and the backers know what those prices are), what could possibly go wrong?
Kalshi’s users buy yes-or-no contracts on future events, each paying $1 if the event happens and nothing if it doesn’t. It is regulated as a derivatives exchange by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), not as a bookmaker, and in 2024 it beat that regulator in court for the right to list contracts on the US election. Roughly 90 percent of its volume is now sports, and more than a dozen states in the US are fighting it as unlicensed gambling. Investors are untroubled: its latest funding round, in October, valued it at $40bn. Abroad it has fared worse. Kalshi itself bars users in 55 jurisdictions, and this year Spain, Brazil and the Czech Republic ordered internet providers to block it. In Switzerland, the gambling regulator Gespa treats prediction markets as unlicensed gambling and has put Kalshi on its blocklist. ‘The protection afforded by the Swiss Gambling Act does not apply to bets placed on these platforms,’ says Gespa’s director, Manuel Richard.
Artnet News, per the editorial, ‘is not involved in the creation of these markets or the verification of results.’ The reaction was mixed, to put it kindly. Jordan Wolfson left a vomit emoji under the Instagram announcement. Jasmine Wahi, founder of Project for Empty Space, commented: ‘i think this is satire (???!)’.
The pitch was access: when Kalshi opened its art category in May, it promised that ‘investors of all financial backgrounds can now access the asset class.’ Its chief executive, Tarek Mansour, was more direct: ‘The long-term vision is to financialize everything and create a tradable asset out of any difference in opinion.’ The first real test was New York’s November auctions, which closed on Friday 20 November. The marquee evening sales alone made just over $2bn with fees.
Where the Money Went
The Art Journal counted every single-lot market Kalshi listed on the New York sales: 58 of them, across Sotheby’s, Christie’s and Phillips. Together they traded $635,860 from 7127 individual trades. The van Gogh attracted the most trades, at 1134 trades, averaging $5.26 each. Small volumes at low prices, then, for this first outing.
Kalshi reports volume as the number of contracts traded, each counted at its $1 payout whatever was paid for it, so a contract bought for 20 cents adds a dollar, and every resale counts again. The cash actually staked is a fraction of the headline number, and Kalshi does not publish it. Van Gogh’s Châtaigniers en fleurs alone accounted for $97,886, or 15 percent. Nicolas Party’s Yellow Portrait traded $79. The most-traded market in Kalshi’s art category is not a work of art: OG Anunoby’s game-winning tip-in basketball, at $125,153, more than every Phillips lot combined ($104,216). The middle market barely registered.
Kalshi is unfazed. “Across all the Artnet markets listed in the past month there’s been +$500K in total trading volume,” spokesperson Laura Frank told The Art Journal via email. The count roughly bears her out: the 53 Artnet-settled markets traded $490,274.
The punters failed to beat the specialists. Sotheby’s estimated the Van Gogh ‘in the region of $180m’; on 11 November traders gave a 58 percent chance it would clear $200m, according to Adam Schrader in Urgent Matter. It hammered at $165m, below that estimate, and made $190.4m with fees. The house was closer. Traders gave Christie’s Basquiat, Untitled (Leonardo and His Five Grotesque Heads), estimated in the region of $30m, an 80 percent chance of making more than $35m; it sold for $28m hammer, $32.9m with fees.
Rajiv Sethi, an economist at Barnard who studies prediction markets, says letting insiders trade “would discourage others from trading, since insiders would have such a powerful information edge. So the market may have lower participation and volume, and even lower accuracy in the long run.”

Untitled (Leonardo and His Five Grotesque Heads), Jean-Michel Basquiat, Courtesy Christie's
Who Keeps Score
But who are the insiders? The Christie’s, Phillips and November Sotheby’s markets settle on the Artnet Price Database; Kalshi’s filing with the CFTC states that ‘only the Artnet Price Database record governs’. The year-end market on the most expensive work sold at auction settles on an editorial list compiled by Artsy. Both companies say all their staff are barred from trading. Each points at the other: Kalshi “determines how each market resolves”, says the Artnet and Artsy spokesperson, while Kalshi’s filing hands the record to Artnet. Neither will disclose terms.
Both companies belong to Andrew Wolff’s Beowolff Capital, which merged them in April. Sarah Cascone, a former Artnet News writer laid off in that round, says some 50 jobs went, roughly four at Artnet for every one at Artsy. Artsy, she writes, is ‘a tech company that works with art, not an art company that works with tech.’
The View from the Saleroom
The auction houses are harder to police. By Artnet’s own count, 64.2 percent of the estimated value of New York’s seven major evening sales was guaranteed as of publication. Kalshi’s rules exclude anyone with material nonpublic information, but Christie’s published conditions of sale make no mention of prediction markets, though they do flag lots on which a party ‘who may have knowledge of the lot’s reserve or other material information may be bidding.’ Christie’s says its employee policies explicitly cover prediction markets; on consignors, guarantors and irrevocable bidders: “We continue to closely monitor this evolving situation.” Phillips says its policies fully cover “emerging external market technologies connected to our sales”, but speaks only of employees. Sotheby’s did not respond to a request for comment.
Kalshi x Miami Art Week
Artnet said on 11 November that Miami Art Week markets would ‘go live later this month’, though the CFTC filing covers only works sold at public auction, not fair sales, the figures the trade has always kept loosest. Artnet now says: “We aren’t planning markets around self-reported sales. Markets tied to Miami Art Week will settle only on publicly verifiable data.” Kalshi says: “We haven’t listed these markets yet. We are reviewing.” An Art Basel spokesperson said: “Art Basel has not been approached by Kalshi or Artnet regarding prediction markets tied to sales at Art Basel Miami Beach and is not involved in this initiative. Sales at Art Basel fairs take place directly between galleries and their clients. Art Basel is not privy to all transactions, and galleries independently determine what sales information they disclose. Art Basel staff are expected to comply with applicable company policies, including those governing confidential information and conflicts of interest.”
At $636,000 in contract volume across the season’s biggest sales, the stakes are too small to tempt anyone holding a guarantee on a multimillion-dollar work. They are also cheap advertising for a company that now owns a newsroom, a marketplace and the record against which the bets are settled, and which has every reason to want them to grow. A fair booth, where the price is whatever the dealer chooses to say, is where that ambition meets the market as it actually works. How a contract settles there remains to be seen.
Related content
News

Iraq Museum to Reopen Following Two-Year Renovation Project
The Institution, home to tens of thousand Mesopotamian, Sumerian, Babylonian, and Assyrian artifacts, will reopen to the public on 1 December

American Artist Zoe Leonard to Open Museion’s 2027 Programme
Bolzano’s contemporary art museum opens its year with artist Zoe Leonard, as more of its exhibitions travel out to partners in Spain, Switzerland and the Netherlands

ART SG Unveils Fifth-Edition Line-up For Singapore Art Week 2027
ART SG’s fifth edition opens Singapore Art Week in January, bringing more than 110 galleries to Marina Bay Sands in a second year of co-presentation with S.E.A. Focus

Stedelijk Museum Amsterdam Appoints Krist Gruijthuijsen as New Director
The Dutch curator and critic Krist Gruijthuijsen will succeed Rein Wolfs in July 2027

Margot Heller to Step Down as South London Gallery Director
Heller leaves after an over 25-year tenure that saw visitor numbers increase tenfold and the gallery’s footprint more than triple

Ownership Claims Shadow New York Auction Week
Ownership claims have disrupted New York’s biggest auction week of the year, with Sotheby’s settling a restitution claim over its $180 million Van Gogh and Christie’s withdrawing a Frida Kahlo painting

Paris Museum to Lend Works to Hong Kong amid Tibet Dispute
Around 150 objects will trace over a millennium of artistic exchange across Eurasia, in a partnership with a Paris museum facing protests over its labelling of Tibet

Kader Attia Reveals Theme for 2027 Kochi-Muziris Biennale
The artist and curator has unveiled a theme centred on dreams, memory and repair, set against the predictive logic of AI

Dakar Biennale Opens 2026 Edition This Week
The Biennale brings together 74 artists and collectives across the Senegalese capital for a monthlong celebration of contemporary African art and design

Paisley Museum to Reopen in 2027 After £68.7 Million Redevelopment
Closed since 2018, the museum reopens as a single campus of galleries, gardens and the restored Coats Observatory, in the first reimagining of its 150-year history

Sculptures Smashed at Turkish Border Crossing
Sculptures headed for an exhibition set to open in London were smashed at the Turkey–Bulgaria border

Bronze Sculpture by Jean Arp Stolen at Art Cologne
The theft has prompted questions about security at the fair. Ludorff Gallery says the 28cm bronze disappeared from its booth during a 15-minute window on Sunday
